A Separation

Movie poster

“Flawless, elegant, mysterious..a world-class masterpiece”

According to the Wall Street Journal this describes the movie that I saw yesterday.  The film is set in Tehran and focuses on a middle class couple who separate.  The woman Simin wants to leave Iran with her husband Nader and daughter Termeh.   She sues for divorce when Nader refuses to leave behind his Alzheimer-suffering father and determines to take her daughter and leave.

When the judge refuses to agree to the divorce Simin moves out of their house and into her parents house.  The ramifications of this move are what make the movie so compelling.

The two have been married for 14 years and have an 11-year-old daughter.  On their behalf Simin has acquired visas for them to leave Iran, a long drawn out process, but Nader will not leave.  His father, who lives with them suffers from Alzheimer’s and needs constant care.  In desperation Nader hires a woman to look after the house and the old man.  The woman is pregnant, has a daughter whom she brings to the apartment with her and an out of work husband who thinks the world is against him.

We see the difficulty that this devout Muslim woman has with caring to all the physical needs of this old man, and the toll that it takes on her own health.

We follow the story through the woman’s miscarriage, the hospital confrontations between Nader and her husband, the accusations made against Nader by the woman and her husband, the questions raised not only by Simin and their daughter, but also by a judge who must determine whether Nader is responsible for the woman’s miscarriage.

It is a beautifully plotted movie and one well worth seeing.  The dialogue was all Persian but I was not aware that I was reading the subtitles, so compelling was it.  And at the end when the daughter is asked to determine which of her parents she wishes to live with, we are left with no answer.  A cliff hanger indeed!

The critics are in accord with their praise for this movie:

‘Sophisticated, superbly acted and wholly gripping.  Keeps us hooked right until a supremely well-handled close”  Daily Telegraph (UK)

“Riveting.  Grips you like a great thriller”  Vogue (US)

“A superb work.  A triumph of the higher priorities of filmmaking”.  Boston Globe

“Calling it a masterpiece is too mild a compliment” Time Out New York.

So if you get the opportunity to view this movie, I recommend that you take it.

“What a pity human beings can’t exchange problems.  Everyone knows exactly how to solve the other fellow’s.” Olin Miller, 

20 responses to “A Separation

  1. I have heard so much about this film. I’m looking forward to seeing it.


  2. Noted, Judith. I will make plans to see it. Thank you for the recommendation.


  3. Well – I will definitely be looking for this film! You are a great “reviewer” Judith. Thanks for sharing your impressions.


  4. Thanks for the review. I’ve had this movie on my to-be-watched list for a while now.


  5. I haven’t heard of this movie, but it sounds good. The cliffhanger ending would bother me a bit because I’d be left wondering who she would have picked.


    • Yes well the judge asked her had she decided. She nodded and then..the screen went blank and the credits rolled. I too wonder who she would have picked.


  6. I want to see this based on your wonderful review, Judith!


  7. Yep, I’ve heard a lot of good about this film and would like to see it. Thanks for the review…


  8. I had not heard of this film before. It sounds quite interesting. Thanks for sharing it with us. I’ll put it on my movie list. 🙂


  9. Pingback: Book and Movie Updates | WalkieTalkieBookClub's Blog

  10. Thanks for sharing, I enjoy your reviews.


Let's talk

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.